Creamy Tomato and Red Lentil Pasta
Red lentils soften into the tomato sauce, providing body while keeping the ingredient list straightforward. They must be fully tender before the sauce is finished with milk. This is a lentil-based pasta sauce rather than a substitute presented as identical to a meat sauce.

Rather eat it out? See restaurants near you that serve tomato and red lentil pasta.
📍 Find it near me ↗
Creamy Tomato and Red Lentil Pasta
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- Warm oil in a saucepan and soften onion for 6 minutes. Stir in garlic and oregano.
- Add lentils, passata and broth. Simmer partially covered for 20–25 minutes, stirring near the bottom.
- Continue until lentils are completely soft, adding water if the sauce thickens before they cook.
- Cook rigatoni separately according to the package and drain.
- Stir milk into the lentil sauce over low heat. Mash or briefly blend if a smoother sauce is preferred.
- Toss with the pasta and check seasoning. Serve immediately, loosening with hot water if needed.
Notes
Checking the lentils before finishing
Rinse the red lentils and simmer them until completely soft. Tomato sauce can thicken before the lentils are tender, so stir near the base and add water gradually if needed. Increasing the heat to hurry a thick sauce risks scorching it before the grains soften.
Cook the rigatoni separately while the sauce simmers. Add milk over low heat only after the lentils are tender. Mash or briefly blend the sauce if you want a smoother coating, then combine with pasta. If the finished dish tightens as it stands, loosen individual portions with a small amount of hot water.
Ingredient choices and substitutions
Can green lentils be used instead?
They will remain distinct and need different cooking time; use red lentils for this texture.
More recipes to try
MAKE THE MEAL YOURS
Shopping & recipe cost
Shopping list & recipe cost
Planning for 4 servings.
Change yield with the recipe card controls ↑. This planner follows those controls. Quantities written in the method describe the original batch; adjust them too. Cooking time does not multiply.
Tick ingredients you already have to leave them off the shopping list. Ingredient costs still include them. Enter your own pack prices in CAD; no store prices are fetched.
Enter pack prices and amounts to estimate the ingredient cost.
Use the same unit and preparation for pack amount and amount used. For drained ingredients, use the usable drained pack amount. Changing between weight and volume requires your own measured quantity. Excludes energy, travel, taxes, sides and extra ingredients mentioned only in notes.
Prefer to eat out?
No menu-verified restaurant match is recorded for this recipe yet. Browse the restaurant guide.
Saved recipes & shopping list → Meals with shared ingredients →
Recipe by TasteNivo. See our editorial method for recipe preparation and illustrative image notes.
KEEP EXPLORING
Pasta and sauces
Browse the Pasta & Rice collection, or try:
For coating pasta with its sauce, see Finish pasta in sauce.